Hire Future Captains: How Coaching Builds Leaders From Day One
Things worth taking away
- Hire future captains. Josh's airline hires first officers as future captains and screens for leadership in the interview, so development starts on day one, not years in.
- Coaching and mentoring are not the same. A mentor tells you how they would do it; a coach helps you set your own goals and become the architect of your own learning.
- Silence has a cost. A 1994 NTSB study found inadequate crew monitoring or challenging in 31 of 37 major airline accidents (84%) — speaking up is a trained skill, not a personality trait.
- Psychological safety is only half the job. Amy Edmondson's research shows safe teams learn more, but Josh adds that anonymous reporting isn't enough — people also need to feel safe raising a hand in the room.
- Learning styles are a myth. A 2008 review (Pashler and colleagues) found little evidence that teaching to a 'visual' or 'hands-on' style helps; what matters is matching the method to the task.
- This week's experiment: send your team home with two or three real reflection questions — not 'what stood out', but what they will actually use — and talk through the answers the next day. Nathalie adds two of her own: what are you avoiding, and where are you afraid to fail?
About this episode
What if you treated every new hire as a future leader from day one? Nathalie sits down with Josh Bricker — a flight instructor turned pilot examiner who now leads flight operations, training and recruitment at Porter Airlines, holds two MBAs, and is doing doctoral research on leadership in aviation — to explore what it takes to grow leaders from the moment they walk through the door.
Josh explains why his airline hires first officers as future captains and screens for leadership in the interview, how coaching differs from the mentoring he was once hired to do, and why critical reflection — not just flight hours — is what turns pilots into leaders. He and Nathalie dig into psychological safety and the real cost of staying quiet (a 1994 NTSB study found inadequate crew monitoring or challenging in 84% of the major accidents it reviewed), why a non-punitive reporting culture and Brené Brown’s “brave spaces” matter, and why the popular idea of “learning styles” doesn’t hold up.
Along the way they get into AI and VR in pilot training, how being coached quietly turned Josh into a coach, and the connection that makes onboarding and development actually work. The episode closes with an experiment for your week: send your team home with two or three reflection questions worth answering, then talk through them the next day — and Nathalie adds two of her own: what are you avoiding, and where are you afraid to fail?
Josh Bricker is a Coach Academy-certified leadership coach and the Director of Flight Operations, Training & Recruitment at Porter Airlines. Explore Coach Academy’s ICF-accredited, live-online programs at Canada Coach Academy.
Jump to a moment
- 00:00Meet Josh Bricker: 20 years training pilots at Porter
- 01:37His doctoral research: coaching in pilot training
- 04:03The challenge: making captains faster than ever
- 05:42Coaching as a tool for critical reflection
- 09:00Why critical thinkers are harder to hire than you'd think
- 13:05Psychological safety, and the cost of staying quiet
- 15:30Beyond safety: brave spaces and a reporting culture
- 19:29Nathalie's story: "What do you need to be successful?"
- 22:03Architects of their own learning (the learning-styles myth)
- 25:15When does leadership support start?
- 26:51Hire future captains: develop leaders from day one
- 28:25Coaching vs. mentoring, and why the difference matters
- 30:05AI, VR and scenario-based pilot training
- 33:17Inside his action research (it starts tonight)
- 38:02Do goals actually make a difference?
- 43:41Vlogging instead of journaling
- 45:14The awkward feedback-on-camera experiment
- 51:33How being coached turned Josh into a coach
- 54:01Connection, onboarding, and why it's overlooked
- 56:23This week's experiment: reflection questions to take home
- 1:01:10Closing
Keep listening
