Self-Promotion Feels Cringe? How New Coaches Get Found
Things worth taking away
- Being a great coach is not enough. Referrals matter, but Lisa finds clients through media coverage, social media and AI tools like ChatGPT — so you have to be visible where people actually look.
- Use the words your clients actually type. People search 'coach near me', not your jargon. Put their language on your website, then search yourself and check whether you show up in the AI summary at the top.
- Pick 1 to 3 key messages and wrap them in stories. 'Skippy peanut butter is delicious' on repeat is boring; the same message inside a real client story is what people remember.
- Self-promotion feels less cringe when it is generous. Start by liking, commenting on and sharing other people's posts — you help their work get seen, and promotion starts to feel like connection.
- Therapy heals the past; coaching builds what's next. Lisa has benefited from both, and describes coaching as the awareness, accountability and support that get you to act on what you already know.
- This week's experiment: take 10 minutes and write answers to three questions — what do I want more of in my life, what am I avoiding, and what would I do if I couldn't fail?
About this episode
How do new coaches get clients when self-promotion feels cringe? Nathalie sits down with Lisa Murphy, an ICF Professional Certified Coach in Toronto who spent 20 years growing audiences for Canadian magazines before coaching changed her own life at 50 — and who, at 52, trained to become a coach herself. Then she met the part every new coach dreads: getting found.
Lisa explains why being a great coach is not enough on its own, and how the best practices she used to relaunch big brands apply just as well to a solo practice: use the words people actually type (like “coach near me”), check whether you show up in AI search summaries, pick one to three key messages and wrap them in stories so you stay memorable without boring anyone. She and Nathalie get honest about why posting feels cringe, why it gets easier when you start by commenting on and sharing other people’s work, why content takes months of consistency rather than polish, and why getting out of the house still matters in a loneliness epidemic.
The conversation then turns to Lisa’s own story — the hamster wheel she was on at 50, what coaching did for her, and the line she draws between therapy’s focus on healing the past and coaching’s focus on what’s next — before closing with her connection experiment for the week: take 10 minutes and ask yourself what you want more of, what you’re avoiding, and what you’d do if you couldn’t fail.
Lisa Murphy helps midlife women create more intentional, fulfilling and joyful lives, and runs the 50 Forward Club, an Instagram community celebrating women over 50. Find her at coachlisamurphy.com. Explore Coach Academy’s ICF-accredited, live-online programs at Canada Coach Academy.
Jump to a moment
- 00:00Meet Lisa Murphy
- 02:26What connection means in marketing
- 04:07Great coaches still need to be found
- 07:24Use the words your clients actually search
- 11:32Content takes time
- 12:59Post before it's polished
- 14:20When self-promotion feels cringe
- 18:05The Skippy peanut butter rule
- 21:58Know one topic better than anyone
- 23:10Talk to 5 people in your niche
- 26:48Loneliness and getting out of the house
- 30:03Act first, the feeling follows
- 31:36Coaching at 50
- 34:38Would you? Will you?
- 37:43Coaching vs. therapy
- 41:07Purpose can start small
- 45:21The evidence locker
- 49:21The loneliest person in the room
- 50:46Lisa's connection experiment
Keep listening
